George Green Solicitors Banner Image

Employment Law

Employment Law Bulletin: November 2026

Fire and rehire: a very different world from March 2027

At present, “fire and rehire” remains a potentially lawful way of changing contractual terms where agreement cannot be reached. An employer can give notice of dismissal on existing contractual terms and offer re-engagement on amended terms. Such a dismissal may be fair for the potentially fair reason of “some other substantial reason” (SOSR), provided there is a sound business reason for the change and it has acted reasonably, including through proper consultation. The current statutory Code of Practice, introduced in 2024, already stresses that dismissal and re-engagement should be a last resort.

From March 2027, however, the landscape changes fundamentally. That implementation date itself is new: the reforms had previously been expected in January 2027.

Under the Employment Rights Act 2025, dismissal to impose a “restricted variation” will become automatically unfair unless the employer can satisfy a narrow financial difficulties exception. Restricted variations include:

  • reductions to pay or other sums payable in connection with employment;
  • changes to performance-related measures determining pay;
  • changes to pensions;
  • changes to total working hours;
  • specified changes to the timing or duration of shifts;
  • reductions in contractual time off; and
  • inserting a contractual power allowing the employer to make any of these changes without agreement.

The financial difficulties exception sets a deliberately high bar: broadly, the difficulties must threaten the organisation’s ability to continue as a going concern, and the employer must have been unable reasonably to avoid the need for the change. The new draft Code of Practice helpfully explains what financial difficulties might look like in the private sector, the public sector, and for local authority employers.

Dismissals to secure other, unrestricted changes will remain potentially fair for SOSR, but subject to a more demanding statutory fairness framework. The Government’s draft revised Code of Practice provides the practical framework for this brave new world.

There is, however, an unusual wrinkle. The existing 2024 Code is expected to be withdrawn when the new regime starts in March 2027, while the replacement Code is not expected to take effect until summer 2027 – potentially leaving employers navigating the new statutory regime for several months without a Code.

Fire and rehire: why the definition of a ‘restricted variation’ matters

The Government has now confirmed how expenses, benefits in kind and shift patterns will fit within the new fire and rehire regime which is due to come into force in March 2027. For HR, the detail matters because one question will become critical when contractual changes are proposed: is this a “restricted variation”?

Under the Employment Rights Act 2025, restricted variations already include certain changes to core contractual terms, including pay, pensions, hours and time off. The Government’s consultation response fills in some important gaps around the edges of that definition.

Most expenses and benefits in kind will be excluded. However, contractual travel expenses (including mileage), accommodation expenses and long-term accommodation provided as a benefit in kind will remain protected. Share schemes will be outside the restricted category. Importantly, these protections only bite where the relevant entitlement is contractual: changes made under an effective existing variation clause, or to genuinely non-contractual policies, are different.

For shift patterns, the Government has opted for targeted protection. A contractual change requiring someone to move from day to night working (11pm–6am), or vice versa, or from weekday to weekend working, or vice versa, will be restricted. Changes to availability windows will not. Nor will less fundamental changes, such as moving a daytime shift by a few hours.

Why does the label matter so much?

Because it determines the legal route that follows. Dismissing an employee because they refuse a restricted variation will generally be automatically unfair, unless the employer can satisfy the narrow statutory exception for serious financial difficulties.

By contrast, dismissal to implement an unrestricted variation is not automatically unfair. Instead, it falls into the ordinary unfair dismissal regime, with the slight tweak that tribunals are required to consider statutory factors including the reason for the change, consultation and anything offered in return for agreement.

For HR, therefore, identifying precisely what is being changed – and how the existing contract is drafted – needs, from March 2027, to become the starting point of every contractual change exercise.

Pregnancy and family leave: a new test for dismissal

Pregnant employees and new parents already benefit from significant dismissal protection. Dismissal because of pregnancy or maternity is automatically unfair and potentially discriminatory, while separate rules give priority for suitable alternative vacancies in redundancy situations during pregnancy, family leave and specified periods afterwards.

From October 2027, however, that framework will become significantly more protective. Earlier this year, the Government held a public consultation on proposed enhanced dismissal protections for pregnant employees and those taking family leave. This change had been outlined in broad terms in the Employment Rights Act 2025, but the detail was to be left to regulations. The Government has now published the result of that consultation which will shape those regulations.

The Government has confirmed that employees who are pregnant, on maternity or certain other forms of family leave, or within the relevant post-leave period, will benefit from an enhanced test governing any potentially fair dismissal.

The five existing fair reasons – conduct, capability, redundancy, illegality and some other substantial reason – will remain. What changes is the test of fairness.

Ordinarily, tribunals ask whether dismissal fell within the “band of reasonable responses”: they cannot substitute their own decision simply because they would have acted differently. For protected employees, that will be replaced by the objective justification test familiar from discrimination law. Employers will have to demonstrate that dismissal was a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

That is a materially higher hurdle. It also puts the tribunal’s view of dismissal back in play – the tribunal will be making its own judgment, upon a fair and detailed analysis of all the circumstances involved, as to whether the dismissal was reasonably necessary. This is going to mean, where a dismissal of a protected employee is contemplated, employers need to demonstrate that reasonably viable alternatives - such as additional support, temporary adjustments or redeployment - were properly explored before dismissal.

Protection will be a day-one right and, for pregnancy, will start once the employer is informed. For maternity leave, it will continue until six months after leave ends. Adoption leave receives equivalent protection, while shared parental, neonatal care and bereaved partner’s paternity leave will also qualify, with six months’ post-leave protection where at least six continuous weeks are taken.

Importantly, the existing enhanced redundancy regime remains alongside these rules.

For HR, this means identifying protected employees early and building objective justification into decision making on dismissals. From October 2027, showing that a potentially fair dismissal was reasonable will no longer necessarily be enough.

Whistleblowing law: is it time for a rethink?

Whistleblowing protection has been part of UK employment law for almost 30 years. Now, the Government has launched the widest review of the framework since the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998.

So, what could change?

What is protected now?

Not every complaint at work amounts to whistleblowing. Broadly, an individual must disclose information which they reasonably believe shows one of seven types of wrongdoing: a criminal offence; breach of a legal obligation; miscarriage of justice; danger to health and safety; that sexual harassment has occurred, is occurring or is likely to occur; environmental damage; or deliberate concealment of any of these.

They must also reasonably believe that making the disclosure is in the public interest.

How and to whom the disclosure is made can also matter. Disclosure to an employer attracts relatively straightforward protection, while disclosures to certain external bodies, known as prescribed persons, and wider disclosures are subject to additional conditions.

Where the requirements are met, workers are protected against being subjected to a detriment because they have blown the whistle. Employees who are dismissed for doing so can claim automatically unfair dismissal, without needing the usual qualifying service.

There is also the unusual remedy of interim relief. An employee who claims they were dismissed for whistleblowing can, in certain circumstances, ask a tribunal to preserve their employment or pay pending the full hearing. Currently, the application must be made within just seven days of dismissal.

What could change?

The Government's consultation is wide-ranging. It considers extending protection to groups including some self-employed people, non-executive directors, charity trustees and job applicants, as well as changing the rules around qualifying disclosures and who disclosures can be made to.

For HR, perhaps the most significant proposal is a new legal duty to maintain whistleblowing policies and procedures, potentially applying to private sector employers with 50 or more employees and backed by civil penalties.

The Government is also considering extending the interim relief deadline from seven to fourteen days, alongside a proposed SFO financial reward scheme for some whistleblowers reporting economic crime.

These are proposals rather than law, but they signal a potentially significant shift: from whistleblowing being primarily about protecting individuals who speak up, to placing greater responsibility on organisations to create effective systems for them to do so.

The consultation closes on 8 January 2027.

Harassment: when does unwanted conduct cross the line?

A poorly judged comment does not automatically amount to harassment under the Equality Act 2010. A recent EAT decision provides a useful reminder of the test HR should apply.

In McManus v British Airways, a cabin crew member with anxiety and depression was preparing to return from long-term sickness absence. During an occupational health assessment, she was told that Access to Work was “not for people like you, it’s for people in wheelchairs”.

The tribunal accepted that the comment related to her disability and that she felt harassed by it. However, her harassment claim still failed.

What is the test for harassment?

Under the Equality Act 2010, harassment occurs where there is unwanted conduct related to a relevant protected characteristic which has the purpose or effect of violating someone’s dignity, or creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment.

Where the complaint is about the effect of the conduct, HR should remember that an employee’s perception is important, but it is not decisive.

The tribunal must consider:

  • the employee’s perception;
  • the other circumstances of the case; and
  • whether it was reasonable for the conduct to have that effect.  

McManus confirms that a claimant’s mental ill health can be relevant when considering that final question. It is not simply relevant to explaining why the employee experienced the conduct in a particular way. However, mental ill health does not automatically make their reaction objectively reasonable.

What should HR take from this?

When investigating harassment allegations, avoid asking simply: “Was the employee offended?”

Instead, consider the whole picture. What was said or done? What was the context? How did the employee experience it? Are there personal circumstances relevant to that reaction? And, taking everything together, was it reasonable for the conduct to have the harassing effect alleged?

Context matters. So does the individual. Neither should be considered in isolation.

Employment status: is the worker test about to change?

Employee, worker or self-employed? It is a distinction that matters enormously in employment law, because the answer determines which rights an individual receives.

Employees sit at the top of the hierarchy, benefiting from the full range of employment rights, including unfair dismissal and redundancy protection. “Workers” occupy the middle ground. They do not receive the full suite of employee rights but qualify for important protections including the National Minimum Wage and paid holiday. The genuinely self-employed generally sit outside the employment rights framework altogether.

The problem is that deciding which box someone falls into is not always straightforward.

Why does substitution matter?

For someone to qualify as either an employee or worker, the current law requires an obligation to provide personal service. In simple terms, they must be required to do the work themselves.

That puts considerable weight on rights of substitution. A genuine, unrestricted ability to send someone else to perform the work will generally be inconsistent with personal service, even if substitution rarely happens in practice.

The Government thinks that can produce the wrong result. An individual might, for example, be subject to significant control over how they work but nevertheless fall outside worker protection because they have a genuine right to provide a substitute. Its new consultation therefore proposes giving greater prominence to “significant direction or control”. This could operate as an alternative route to worker status, meaning that the absence of personal service would no longer necessarily end the enquiry. The aim is to prevent substitution clauses outweighing other features of a relationship which point strongly towards worker status.

And this may only be the beginning…

The Government is also considering a presumption of worker status, placing the burden on the engager to establish that an individual is genuinely self-employed.

More fundamentally, its longer-term ambition remains a single status of “worker”, removing the distinction between employees and workers and potentially extending full employment protection to everyone falling within that status. For now, however, the three-tier framework remains firmly in place.

For HR, the immediate message is not to rewrite consultancy agreements. These are proposals, not law. But organisations with significant contractor, freelance or gig workforces should watch closely. A change to the status test could significantly widen the group entitled to employment rights.

The consultation closes on 8 January 2027.

Mitigation of loss: the burden is on the employer

A claimant who succeeds in the employment tribunal is expected to take reasonable steps to mitigate their financial loss. But there is an important distinction between that obligation and the question of who must prove that it has been breached.

The Employment Appeal Tribunal’s decision in Kirkland v Mason provides a useful reminder that the burden rests firmly on the employer.

What must the employer establish?

Ms Kirkland successfully claimed unfair dismissal following her summary dismissal from a part-time administration manager role. She sought compensation for 19 months’ loss of earnings.

The tribunal limited her award to six months. It was not satisfied that she had adequately mitigated her loss and considered that she had chosen to concentrate on developing a short-term property letting business, rather than seeking alternative employment.

The EAT overturned that decision.

The problem was the tribunal’s approach to the burden of proof. It was not for Ms Kirkland to satisfy the tribunal that she had taken reasonable steps to mitigate. The relevant question was whether the employer had proved that she had unreasonably failed to do so.

A tribunal cannot therefore reduce compensation simply because it considers that a claimant could have done more. There must be a finding that the claimant acted unreasonably, and the evidential burden of establishing that rests with the employer.

What does mitigation require?

The test is not whether the claimant took every possible step to minimise their loss. Nor is the tribunal entitled simply to substitute its own view of what it would have done in the same circumstances.

The focus is on reasonableness. A claimant has considerable latitude in deciding how to respond to dismissal, provided their approach falls within the range of reasonable steps open to them.

That can make mitigation arguments more difficult than they sometimes appear. Evidence that a claimant made relatively few job applications, changed career direction or pursued self-employment does not necessarily establish an unreasonable failure to mitigate.

The evidential challenge for employers

Where mitigation is genuinely in issue, employers need to identify both the alleged unreasonable conduct and the loss which would probably have been avoided had reasonable steps been taken.

That may require evidence about the availability of suitable vacancies, likely remuneration, the claimant’s skills and experience and the realistic timescale within which alternative employment could have been secured. Kirkland therefore highlights an important distinction at remedy stage: identifying weaknesses in a claimant’s attempts to mitigate is not the same as proving a failure to mitigate.

For employers seeking a reduction in compensation, the latter is what matters.

And Finally...

It is not every payroll dispute that attracts the attention of the captain of the USS Enterprise.

But William Shatner, better known as Star Trek’s Captain Kirk, recently waded into a row between Aldi and a former employee over a £97.64 wage overpayment.

The employee’s father, radio presenter Chris Brooks, posted on X after his son received a letter from Aldi seeking repayment following the end of his employment. Brooks described the letter as “intimidating”, particularly because it warned of debt recovery action if payment was not made by a date which, according to Brooks, had already passed before the letter was even sent.

Enter Captain Kirk.

Shatner responded publicly, criticising Aldi’s accounting department and suggesting that the company should work out how much it had spent pursuing the debt. He suspected it might be more than the £97 at stake.

There is, however, a serious HR point lurking beneath the celebrity intervention.

Employers are generally entitled to recover genuine accidental overpayments of wages. While someone remains employed, an overpayment is also one of the recognised exceptions to the usual restrictions on deductions from wages. But where employment has already ended and there are no further wages from which to make a deduction, the employer will normally need to ask the former employee to repay the money and, ultimately, consider a civil claim if they refuse. Acas recommends explaining the overpayment and being fair and flexible about repayment.

Having a legal right to recover money does not mean it needs to be exercised at maximum warp speed.

A proportionate first letter, explaining what has happened, apologising for the employer’s error and inviting the individual to discuss repayment is likely to achieve more than an immediate threat of debt recovery, particularly where the sum is modest.

In this case, Aldi subsequently apologised for the concern caused and confirmed that it would not pursue the money after all.

Perhaps the HR lesson is simple: before sending the stern template letter, consider whether a more human approach might help everyone to live long and prosper.